Work with Jacksonville's Rental Experts

We've Helped Countless Landlords

Don't find yourself working with an inexperienced management team. Instead, choose a firm that's already helped hundreds of property owners.

We Provide Great Support

When you find yourself in a tricky situation, you want to know you're not alone. Our team works to provide the best support possible & is always happy to help.

24/7 Online Portal Access

Access the digital account portal at any time to view your recent financial statements and inspection notes.

We Only Focus on Property Management

We aren’t realtors disguised as property managers. We only do property management so you get our full focus rather than an afterthought.

Rental Guys Property Management logo

About Rental Guys Property Management

Want a property manager that works as hard as you do? We understand that your property portfolio probably represents the  greatest investment you have made and our property managers treat it that way.

We work with investors and home owners  across Jacksonville  and the surrounding areas  who want better returns , less stress and asset protection.  Property management is all we do and we are here to make sure you benefit from our know-how.

We realize choosing a property management company is no small decision and one too often based on the initial fee (often a percentage of the monthly rent). Rental Guys Property Management guides the Property Owner through the process (quickly grasping what they need) and then ensures that all parties involved in delivering that service, get the result they want . Finding an agency who delivers the service you want is key to a long (and prosperous) relationship.

“Don’t make the mistake of  putting your extraordinary property in the hands of an ordinary team”

Meet Our Management Team

Brian Alterman - Broker - Jacksonville FL

Brian Alterman


Brian loves working with seasoned property investors.  He now leads our Rental Guys team, ensuring high standards are consistently met and our team is thoroughly trained.  Holding a degree in Real Estate and Marketing from the University of Central Florida, Brian possesses impressive knowledge in number crunching and he works  tirelessly to make sure your rental property stays profitable.  Before coming to Rental Guys, Brian headed the internet  division of one of the largest water sports stores in the world. His knowledge of internet marketing gives you a definite edge, ensuring your home is seen by the largest audience of prospective renters possible.

Why Brian?

If you are looking for someone to give you straight answers while building your rental portfolio then Brian is your man. You won't get  empty promises and the run around, just clear solutions to get you the best results.  Brian has the savvy and know how to work with investors in the ever changing real estate tides.

Shelley Alterman Director of Property Management Jacksonville FL

Shelley Alterman

Director of Property Management

Shelley is going a million miles an hour always balancing spinning plates. Her ability to keep things moving and her advanced problem solving is a perfect fit for property management. After obtaining her bachelors in Public Relations at the University of South Florida, Shelley began working in the multi-family real estate industry. Here, she learned the skills needed for property management, from listening to renters concerns, to working with the maintenance staff and keeping up to date on Florida tenant-landlord laws. A leader in the property management industry, she has been on the board of the local and state NARPM and is one of only a handful of realtors with the RMP(Residential Management Professional) designation in the entire state of Florida .
As the founder of Rental Guys ,Shelley is the visionary for the company. As far as she's concerned, 4 stars is not good enough...she aims for excellence in all that she does.

Why Shelley?

If you are looking for someone who is a master at diffusing difficult situations with communication and quick decision making then working with Shelley will be just what you want.

Erin Morgan Leasing Director Jacksonville FL

Erin Morgan

Leasing Director

Erin believes property ( yes, even rental property) deserves to be presented in the best possible light, with plenty of information to attract the best tenants.  And the results speak for themselves, reduced  vacancy  time and strong rents, consistently.Erin has an impressive resume in the real estate industry. She was formerly the head of marketing for a local hedge fund with over two thousand local rental properties. She also worked with another firm that represented over 1800 doors! Her extensive background allows her to bring unbeatable expertise to her work for our clients. She has served on the board for the local NARPM chapter.

Erin is not only knowledgeable about the local rental market, but she's determined to get top rental dollar for our owners, making her an invaluable asset for our team.

Why Erin?

Want to build wealth through real estate?  Need someone in your corner? Erin is a asset to those committed to building wealth  through real estate.   With some of the highest rents in the area and the knowledge to get  property rented fast you want Erin in your corner



Elliott Greenberg

Broker/Business Development

Coming from a background in real estate sales Elliott has the knowledge on what it takes to get your property rented. Properties that are prepared to rent rather than just thrown on the market tend to get better quality tenants, rent for higher dollar amounts and rent faster. Starting his property management career on the leasing side with one of the country’s largest real estate hedge funds he learned what tenants expect when renting a home. This is important knowledge to have when working with our owners/investors. Communication is a top priority with Elliott and keeping our owners in the loop as much or little as they want.

Why Elliott?

Elliott is dedicated to serving our owners/investors needs. He has a way of going that extra mile to get the job done. Understanding the needs of property owners and tenants alike and can answer all of your real estate questions.

Ed Alterman Maintenance Coordinator Jacksonville FL

Ed Alterman

Maintenance Coordinator

Ed is extremely detail-oriented and works tirelessly to keep our homes looking their best. He previously worked in his family retail business where customer service was a key to their success. He also owns a promotional products company and the same skills he learned in this field cross over into real estate, such as attention to small details and keeping customers informed on the progress of their repairs. Ed handles  the maintenance scheduling and makes sure the homes are kept in good repair. He works closely with the vendors to make sure the repairs are done correctly the first time.


Why Ed?

If you are looking to improve your returns Ed  is   the perfect balance of   keeping your property well maintained  and  property management   knowledge.

Customers Love Our Team

We provide freedom from the nightmare of DIY management

”Rental Guys has been an awesome asset and invaluable to me at a time when I needed someone like you the most. I feel as if I couldn’t have gotten luckier with any other property manager.”

 – M.McDonald, Satisfied Client

"I am so THANKFUL for your hard work and dedication. Thank you for making this happen so quickly! I am just overwhelmed with appreciation and wanted to let your team know.”

 — Amy C., Satisfied Client

NEFAR logo NARPM logo REIA logo Equal Housing Opportunity Best Property Management Jacksonville FL 2019 Award E Town Certified 2024 AgentFlat fee housesCertified Nocatee 2024 Agent

Get a Free Rental Analysis

  1. Learn how much your home could earn monthly.
  2. Find simple ways to boost your earnings
  3. See if our approach fits your investment goals.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Real, Recent Reviews

Talk to Us About Your Rental Needs

We are a team committed to the highest standards. Let's get started today: 904-254-2766tel:904-254-2766